Framing around window and door openings
Construction Insights

Comparing the true cost of buying a bigger home with adding space to the one you already own

Your family is growing, you’re working from home, or parents are moving in, and the house feels small. Most people’s first thought is to sell and buy something bigger. But in Greater Vancouver, the cost of moving alone can be enough to pay for a good part of an addition. Here’s how to compare the two properly.

In short: moving costs money that buys you no extra space: property transfer tax, realtor fees, legal fees and moving costs. An addition puts that money into your own home, but it needs a permit, takes time and depends on what your lot allows.

The costs of moving that add no space

When you buy in BC, you pay property transfer tax: 1% on the first $200,000, 2% on the portion up to $2,000,000 and 3% above $2,000,000, with an extra 2% on residential value over $3,000,000. On a $1,800,000 home that’s $34,000, before realtor fees on the home you sell, legal fees and moving costs.

Property transfer tax on a $1.8M home$34,000Realtor fees to sell (estimate)$50,000Legal, moving & other costs (estimate)$10,000Money spent on moving that doesn’t add any space to your home (illustration)
Example: costs of selling one home and buying a $1.8M home. Tax is calculated from BC’s rates; realtor, legal and moving costs are rough estimates and vary.

And the new home costs more to buy, too. If you need one more bedroom, the price difference between your home and a bigger one is often much larger than the cost of building that room.

What an addition can look like

Existing house Rear addition or2nd storey
Two common ways to add space: a rear addition or going up a storey.
  • Rear or side addition: a new family room, bedroom or larger kitchen, if setbacks and lot coverage allow.
  • Second storey: often the best option on smaller lots, but the existing foundation and structure need an engineer’s review.
  • Finishing or converting space: a basement, garage or attic can sometimes add living space for less.
Wall framing with window and door openings
Framing for new rooms. An addition is built and inspected like a small new home.

What decides whether an addition makes sense

  1. What your zoning allows: setbacks, height and lot coverage set the maximum size.
  2. The existing structure: an older foundation may need upgrades to carry a second storey.
  3. Living through it: rear additions often let you stay in the home; a second storey usually means moving out for part of the job.
  4. Permits and time: an addition needs a building permit, drawings and often engineering.
  5. Your long-term plans: if you’ll stay 10+ years, an addition usually makes more sense than if you’ll move in 3.

How to compare the two

Write down two numbers: the full cost of moving (taxes, fees, the price difference and moving costs) and the cost of the addition you need. Ask a builder for a rough addition budget after a site visit. It’s free with us, and it’s the fastest way to see which option is cheaper for your family.

Related reading

Please note: This page is general information, not legal, financial or professional advice. The facts, figures, bylaws, fees and code requirements described here were accurate to the best of our knowledge when it was published or last updated. These rules change often and differ from city to city, so some details may have changed since. Before you make decisions, please confirm the current requirements with your city’s planning and building department and with qualified professionals. We’re always happy to help you check what applies to your property.

Not sure whether to move or add on? Book a free site visit and we’ll give you a rough addition budget.

Call 604-786-7000Book a Free Site Visit

Sources

Rules and figures change over time. Confirm the current requirements for your property with your municipality and qualified professionals.

Mandeep Singh, Builder and Director at Xerox Builders
Written by
Mandeep Singh
Builder & Director, Xerox Builders Ltd. · BC Housing Licensed Residential Builder

Mandeep has been a licensed residential builder in BC for almost 10 years. He builds custom homes, laneway homes, duplexes and multiplexes in Vancouver, Burnaby, Surrey and Delta, and writes these guides so homeowners know what to expect before they build.

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

Recent Works

Tags